Best Outdoor Grills for Your Backyard
A great grill is the anchor of every backyard cookout—but the wrong one means fighting with flare-ups, running out of space halfway through a family dinner, or realizing the build quality doesn’t survive a single Midwest winter. We’ve done the homework so you don’t have to.
Our editors compared build quality, cooking performance, real-world customer reviews, current pricing, and availability across five major retailers. These are the five picks we’d buy—one per retailer, so you can shop wherever fits your timeline and budget.
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
We evaluated grills across five fuel types and price points, putting real weight on the things manufacturers obscure: actual heat consistency across the grate (not just peak BTU), grate material durability over multiple seasons, build quality at the hinges and control knobs, and whether the warranty is backed by a service network you can actually use.
We read 1-star reviews specifically—that’s where you learn about flare-up issues, rust patterns, and ignitor failures that product pages never mention. One pick per retailer so you can choose based on your shopping preference, return policy comfort level, and price point.
What to Know Before You Buy
Gas is instant-on and precise—turn a knob and you’re cooking in minutes. Pellet adds genuine wood-smoke flavor with set-and-forget ease via an auger that feeds pellets automatically. Charcoal delivers the highest heat and best sear but needs 20–30 minutes to come up to temp. Pick gas if convenience is the priority, pellet if flavor is, charcoal if you love the ritual.
BTU measures heat output, not quality. A well-insulated 30,000 BTU grill outperforms a cheap 60,000 BTU model every time. More important is cooking area. 400 sq in handles 4 burgers comfortably; 600+ handles a full family cookout with room for indirect-heat zones. Buy for the size crowd you actually cook for.
Porcelain-enameled cast iron holds heat best and releases food cleanly—it’s the gold standard for grill grates. It chips if dropped, so handle with care. Stainless steel grates are durable and low-maintenance but don’t retain heat quite as well. Chrome-plated grates are entry-level—they rust faster and stick more. Avoid them if you plan to grill more than occasionally.
All grills need occasional deep cleaning: grates, burner tubes, and grease trap. Gas grills need a spider and insect check on the burner venturis each spring—blockages cause dangerous flare-backs. Pellet grills need an ash cleanout after every 4–5 cooks. A quality grill cover and regular cleaning are the two things that separate a 15-year grill from a 3-year grill.
Our Top 5 Outdoor Grill Picks
Selected across 5 retailers. Prices current at time of publication — check retailer for live pricing.
Weber built its reputation on grills that simply work—reliably, year after year—and the Spirit II E-310 is the clearest expression of that philosophy. Three stainless steel burners push 30,000 BTU across 529 sq in of porcelain-enameled cast-iron grates that hold heat evenly and release food without sticking. The porcelain enamel resists rust even when the cover comes off in a rainstorm. Side tables give you real prep room on both sides. Weber backs this grill with a 10-year warranty and has more authorized service centers in North America than any other grill brand. This is the one we’d recommend to anyone who wants a gas grill that they’ll never have to think about buying again.
- Best-in-class build quality for the price
- Largest dealer & service network
- Porcelain grates resist rust season after season
- 10-year warranty is the best in this segment
- Higher price than comparable BTU competitors
- Side tables not foldable on the base model
If you want real wood-smoke flavor without tending a fire all afternoon, the Traeger Pro 575 is the answer. The D2 drivetrain feeds pellets automatically and holds temperatures with precision from 165°F for low-and-slow smoking all the way to 500°F for a respectable sear. WiFIRE app control lets you monitor and adjust the cook from your phone—walk away from the grill and it keeps working. At 575 sq in, there’s room for a brisket and a full rack of ribs simultaneously. This is a true 6-in-1 machine: grill, smoke, bake, roast, braise, and BBQ. If you’ve never experienced set-and-forget wood-fire cooking, the Pro 575 is the right starting point.
- True set-and-forget cooking
- Wi-Fi monitoring from your phone
- Genuine wood-smoke flavor every cook
- Versatile—not just a grill
- Pellets cost more than propane over time
- Slower preheat than a gas grill
- Not ideal for ultra-high-heat searing
The Blackstone 36” is the most versatile outdoor cooking surface on this list—and it’s not particularly close. With 720 sq in of cold-rolled steel griddle top and four independently controlled burners pushing 60,000 BTU total, you can cook breakfast for eight on one end while smashing burgers on the other. The grease management system channels runoff into a rear catch cup so cleanup is faster than any traditional grill. Foldable side shelves give you prep and plating room. If you entertain, cook for a large family, or want to do breakfast foods outdoors, nothing on this list touches it. Note: the steel top requires seasoning before first use and needs oiling after each cook to prevent rust—that’s the tradeoff for its cooking performance.
- Massive cooking surface for large crowds
- Incredible for breakfast, smash burgers, stir fry
- Faster cleanup than traditional grill grates
- Most versatile outdoor cook surface available
- Requires seasoning before first use
- Surface rusts if not maintained and oiled
- No lid—can’t do traditional indirect grilling
The Nexgrill 4-Burner at Home Depot is the best value-per-spec you’ll find at the $299 price point. Four burners deliver 36,000 BTU across 630 sq in of total cooking area with porcelain-coated cast-iron grates that distribute heat evenly and clean up well. A dedicated side burner handles sauces, side dishes, or boiling corn while the main grill stays focused on the proteins. Built-in thermometer, tool hooks, and foldable side tables round out a genuinely functional setup. If you prefer same-day Home Depot pickup or want an easy in-store return option, this is the pick without hesitation.
- Best value-for-spec at the HD price point
- Reliable, even heat across all four burners
- Side burner included—rare at this price
- Solid warranty and easy HD returns
- Lighter build than premium brands like Weber
- Plastic knobs feel budget-tier
The Char-Broil Classic 280 is the lowest-barrier entry to backyard gas grilling—and it earns its spot on this list by doing the basics well at a price that removes every excuse not to grill. Two burners push 20,000 BTU across 280 sq in of porcelain-coated grates, which is enough for four burgers or two racks of chicken thighs. Push-button ignition, a side shelf, a lid-mounted thermometer, and straightforward assembly mean you’re cooking within an hour of unboxing. The compact footprint works on small decks and balconies where a four-burner setup simply won’t fit. If you’re buying your first gas grill or need a backup unit for a secondary space, this is the honest pick.
- Lowest barrier to entry for gas grilling
- Compact footprint for small decks
- Easy to assemble in under an hour
- Good Char-Broil customer support
- Small cooking area limits meal size
- Lighter build than mid-range models
- Less precise temperature control than premium grills
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Grill | Type | Cooking Area | Price | Retailer | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weber Spirit II E-310 Best Overall | Gas (Propane) | 529 sq in | $449 | Amazon | Shop → |
| Traeger Pro 575 Best Pellet | Wood Pellet | 575 sq in | $799 | Amazon | Shop → |
| Blackstone 36” 4-Burner Best Griddle | Gas Griddle | 720 sq in | $397 | Walmart | Shop → |
| Nexgrill 4-Burner 36,000 BTU | Gas (Propane) | 630 sq in | $299 | Home Depot | Shop → |
| Char-Broil Classic 280 Best Value | Gas (Propane) | 280 sq in | $179 | Amazon | Shop → |
Grill Questions, Answered
A quality propane grill lasts 5–15 years with proper maintenance. Weber’s cast-aluminum fireboxes can go 20+ years with basic care. The biggest longevity factor is whether you clean the grill after each use and keep a properly fitted cover on it between cooks. Rust kills grills far faster than heat does—and it’s entirely preventable.
A standard 20 lb propane tank lasts approximately 18–20 hours on a medium-heat grill. At high heat across all burners, plan on about 10 hours per tank. A good habit to build: always have a spare tank on hand so a low tank doesn’t end a cookout early.
Yes, with a proper-fitting cover. Quality grills are built for outdoor exposure, but UV radiation and moisture degrade ignitors, control valves, and grates over time. A cover extends grill life significantly—especially for the ignition components, which are the most failure-prone part of any gas grill. A $30 cover is cheap insurance on a $400 grill.
Use a smoker box or a foil pouch filled with dry wood chips—hickory, apple, or cherry work well—and place it directly over a burner on high until it starts smoking actively. Then reduce to your target cooking temp. You won’t replicate a dedicated pellet or charcoal grill, but you’ll add noticeable smoke character to chicken, ribs, and pork without buying a second cooker.
Browse All Top Picks
Pergolas, patio furniture, fire pits, outdoor lighting—our editors pick the best across every backyard category.